I had forgotten about this thread. I did end up getting my pooch a cake from Bones and Cones. It had peanut butter and cream cheese icing and kinda looked like a big granola bar on the inside. He loved it! I ended up having him finish it over a few nights so not to give him a gut ache.
And the people at B&C were super friendly and provided great service. Highly recommended for spoiled pets.
Lemme see if I can find the pics.......